Operational route

Review before ship

Make plausible agent output answer to the approved spec, the changed artifacts, and the selected review posture.

Review decisionroute_review_loop

/guild:guild "Review this implementation against the approved spec." --review=cross

Route comparison

Same job. A visible operating record.

Without a route record

Review can become another chat answer with no packet, independence status, checksum binding, or durable result.

With Guild Stack

Guild Stack writes review packets and results under the run record, with cross-host review as the strong form and weaker modes recorded.

Route stops

01
Packet issued
The reviewed artifact, scope, and evidence are packaged for the review round.
02
Independence recorded
Cross-host review is strong; same-host or skipped review is recorded as weaker.
03
Findings loop
Blocking findings route back through bounded rework instead of disappearing into chat.
04
Gate pass rule
Artifact binding, result status, and blockers determine pass or rework.

Receipts

01
Path review/<gate>/packet-<round>.md

Role
Review request bound to scope and artifact evidence.
02
Path review/<gate>/result-<round>.json

Role
Structured verdict and blocker state.
03
Path review/<gate>/trail.md

Role
Human-readable review trail.
04
Path verify.md

Role
Done-gate evidence after review resolves.